Showing posts with label Shakugan no Shana. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shakugan no Shana. Show all posts
Series Review: Shakugan no Shana F (2/10)
Posted by
du5k
Labels:
Series Review,
Shakugan no Shana
Instant summary: Yuji joins the sworn enemies of Shana and wages a war against her and all of her kind. (What?!)
Don't worry if you think that you've missed out something; the series did briefly touched on the events that happened between the last season and this, but there are no other anime in between. I heard you're supposed to read up on the novel to find out the reason of the sudden change in story direction, but well, the producers doesn't seem to care whether you know or not.
I should note that that instant summary sums up 90% of what the show is about. The whole of SnS Final is one huge, lengthy, drawn-out war with many battles spread out across the 24 episodes. So effectively SnS is now a war anime. When I was told that SnS would warp up in this season with the cumulation of everything that the title was about, I didn't expect a war between the two factions in the story; and I certainly didn't expect the whole season to be about a god damn war. In fact, they pulled tons of new characters out of nowhere to increase the scale of the war, which includes fat nun whose ultimate attack is a flying kick. Fat nun ultimate flying kick. I'll let you digest that for a moment.
What about the original selling point of a normal guy fighting for his existence, the supernatural being that integrates into the protagonist's society, the relationship triangle between a human and the supernatural being, and the enemy that pops up every now and then? Sorry, the producers sent his regards; it says to go fuck yourselves.
And no, there are no plot twists and surprises or whatsoever. Every now and then they pull off a different form of I Am Not Left-Handed or Reason Worth Living For, but that's it.
You know what I always hated about SnS? All the jargon, complicated details, complicated character design, and all that theory about existence... none of which are what makes the show interesting, since they're there simply as a setup. And because of this war, we're introduced to tons of new names, abilities, history, etc of people we never cared about before this season. All to please the novel fans?
Okay, I'll actually talk about the story now. The whole idea behind the entire story of SnS Final is that Yuji is fighting for a cause he couldn't tell Shana, or to get her to agree. If I had just one complain about the show, it's that I don't buy that. Not only does the end not justify the means, I just couldn't see how it couldn't have worked out between the two. Even if it doesn't work out, I don't see how it would have worked out like this in the end, even if I ignore that fact that it's all too convenient for him to gain the power to do so. Right up till the end, I can't kick the feeling that the writer is just trying his best to come up with a convincing reason for them to fight each other (which failed). You think it's a happy ending? He just advertently caused the death of heaps of people.
(sigh)
Plot/Concept: ಠ_ಠ
Story Style: Good (Very good, actually)
Audio/Visual: Fair (never liked the color scheme of SnS)
Value: 2
December and Fall '11 Roundup
Posted by
du5k
Labels:
Ben-To,
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai,
Ika Musume,
Last Exile: Ginyoku no Fam,
Season Review,
Shakugan no Shana,
Tamayura,
Working
This only make sense because I'm only able to catch up with these titles in the past couple of days. (Sorry)
November Roundup
Posted by
du5k
Labels:
Ben-To,
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai,
Guilty Crown,
Ika Musume,
Last Exile: Ginyoku no Fam,
Season Review,
Shakugan no Shana,
Tamayura,
Working
The Good
Shinryaku!? Ika Musume
I guess it's a good thing that I pick back up this series. I hated how literally they translate the manga into the anime, unlike the more elaborate Working, but I guess I just got numb to it. Perhaps this is the best way to animate the extremely simple comedy of Ika Musume.
The ~de geso thing always irks me, but it's funny that Kanemoto Hisako's almost naturally saying it by now. Again, this might just be me getting used to that, but whatever; Ika-Musume is good, almost mindless fun, and that's that. And it's damn awesome that they brought back more mini Ika-chan. The one in episode 5 seems to be an anime original, and if that's true, kudos to them, and keep 'em coming.
Working'!!
Opposite of Ika-Musume, it turns out that Working translates very well from manga to anime. I've talked about the problem with the comedic timing of the show, and in the recent episodes they seemed to have made it work by blending multiple jokes together. Their new love for extended pauses helps as well. I mentioned this before, but the repeated jokes are used to setup towards a different one, so don't fault them for that, although it's much less obvious in the manga. On the downside, Taneshima's over-the-top actions is still pretty irritating.
The next err... "storyline" might just be my favourite one so far, so look forward to the next episode.
Carnival Phantasm
I'm not sure if this one counts, but I really just want to put this pic here.
This parody OVA is fucking awesome.
The Above Average
Last Exile: Ginyoku no Fam
To be honest, I'm quite disappointed in Fam's character. Unlike Gizelle and Millia, it feels like her character never really grew at all since the first episode. Her personality drives the story and vice versa, but her development is lacking. This is quite unlike the first LE where the characters are the primary focus, and a lot of that show had us emphasize with how the characters would react in the chaos of the world. This season feels more like the characters being dragged along with the events of the world, and they are simply adapting to it.
Maybe Gonzo really isn't up to par anymore. The recent episodes lulled and hints of Shangri-la, a terrible series they created years ago that tried too hard to mimic the first LE. The last few episodes pretty much only talks about the progress of their heist and the movements within the Ades government. The plot seems to move along and forgot about the character development.
However, Last Exile: Fam, the Silver Wing is still my favourite series this season. Reasons being that the show never really lost the sense of adventure the first LE brought, and while the world in the story isn't quite as elaborate as I hoped it would be, it still gave you a good feel of how vast it is. And I don't have to remind you that the animation quality is superb.
It looks like things are going to get a lot more exciting from here onwards. The Ades war on refugees is escalating, and Giselle's insecurity/stress/doubt might take a toll on their teamwork. This should be fun to watch.
Tamayura ~Hitotose~
It's hard to "think" about an anime you're supposed to "feel", but I'll try. Tamayura seems to be a step back from Sato Junichi's Aria, because it's lack in the "other element". Slice-of-life series often needs to be paired with a secondary genre for it to work, and Tamayura being very pure slice-of-life... seems to have some problems. But I still enjoy it a lot as compared to the OVA, as the little ways that Potte grew as a character makes the show lovely. I admit that there are always snooze periods in every episode, but the series has succeeds in the overall feel that makes it a SoL genre. And I'm surprised that I really liked those shots that Potte or the other photographers in the story took; even though those moments didn't really take place in the anime at all.
Ben-To
I've dropped this and picked it back up twice. While the series has been incredibly unique and well-presented for how absurd the storyline is, I can't seem to find myself caring about the show. It is entertaining and mildly amusing, but it doesn't make me want to catch the next episode. For all I know, they'll be fighting for another special lunch box with another special fighting style that's uniquely trained in some way. It's like a sports anime for me, a genre which I don't watch.
The problem is, though, I simply have too much free time now and there really isn't enough (good) shows for me. So Ben-To would help me kill time... and make me extremely hungry.
The Below Average
Shakugan no Shana III (Final)
Shana 3, much like Horizon, seems to be filled with jargon I couldn't grasp or care about. I know that it might not be a problem if you followed up after the second season (or the novel), but I didn't like it enough to rewatch that (I never rewatch anime series anyway). The story so far has been incredibly slow. They've spent the last 4 or 5 episodes merely setting up the stage for the epic battle that we got a glimpse of in the first few minutes of episode 1, but how long do you plan to entertain me with people simply moving around the world and preparing for the war? Most of them are new characters we barely knew about too. On the bright side, we're spared the Shana tsundere crap and Yoshida stopped looking like she got dumped every two hours.
Boku ha Tomodachi wa Sukunai
It pisses me off to see Kodaka not helping Yukimura get a clue about Yozora's bullshit.
It pisses me off to see Rika and her sick fetishes.
It pisses me off to see Yozora.
It wasn't as bad as before, but the animation quality has taken quite a dip since the first episode.
At least there's still Sena. She's supposed to be bitch #2, but I can't help but like her.
The Bad
Guilty Crown
I'm still waiting (or hoping) for the good part to start. Maybe I'm in denial, but a part of me refuses to believe that Hiroyuki Yoshino (of Code Geass, Mai-HiME, Gundam SEED and Macross Frontier) could pen something like this. I'll like to think that they wrote this with an epic plot twist or ending in mind, and they're just doing whatever they want before they got there. "Epic" as in Madoka-level epic, enough for them to not care about what's really going on in the final product.
I get the feeling I'll be disappointed in the end anyway. They've reached new heights on not giving a shit about what the audience thinks. I haven't seen anything so bad since Tayutama. And the characters are way too bland and inconsistent to make a plot twist work, much less an ending.
I wish I picked another show to blog. Damn you Guilty Crown, for making me feel guilty if I dropped this.
Others
Kyoukai Senjou no Horizon (On-Hold at episode 4)
Mawaru Penguindrum (On-Hold at episode 8)
Mashiro-Iro Symphony (Dropped at episode 3)
![]() |
I'm about to go Takanashi on Mini-Ika. |
I guess it's a good thing that I pick back up this series. I hated how literally they translate the manga into the anime, unlike the more elaborate Working, but I guess I just got numb to it. Perhaps this is the best way to animate the extremely simple comedy of Ika Musume.
The ~de geso thing always irks me, but it's funny that Kanemoto Hisako's almost naturally saying it by now. Again, this might just be me getting used to that, but whatever; Ika-Musume is good, almost mindless fun, and that's that. And it's damn awesome that they brought back more mini Ika-chan. The one in episode 5 seems to be an anime original, and if that's true, kudos to them, and keep 'em coming.
![]() |
Friend zoned. I feel you, Sato. |
Opposite of Ika-Musume, it turns out that Working translates very well from manga to anime. I've talked about the problem with the comedic timing of the show, and in the recent episodes they seemed to have made it work by blending multiple jokes together. Their new love for extended pauses helps as well. I mentioned this before, but the repeated jokes are used to setup towards a different one, so don't fault them for that, although it's much less obvious in the manga. On the downside, Taneshima's over-the-top actions is still pretty irritating.
The next err... "storyline" might just be my favourite one so far, so look forward to the next episode.
Carnival Phantasm
I'm not sure if this one counts, but I really just want to put this pic here.
This parody OVA is fucking awesome.
The Above Average
![]() |
I thought Vespas of that size are meant for little girls! |
To be honest, I'm quite disappointed in Fam's character. Unlike Gizelle and Millia, it feels like her character never really grew at all since the first episode. Her personality drives the story and vice versa, but her development is lacking. This is quite unlike the first LE where the characters are the primary focus, and a lot of that show had us emphasize with how the characters would react in the chaos of the world. This season feels more like the characters being dragged along with the events of the world, and they are simply adapting to it.
Maybe Gonzo really isn't up to par anymore. The recent episodes lulled and hints of Shangri-la, a terrible series they created years ago that tried too hard to mimic the first LE. The last few episodes pretty much only talks about the progress of their heist and the movements within the Ades government. The plot seems to move along and forgot about the character development.
However, Last Exile: Fam, the Silver Wing is still my favourite series this season. Reasons being that the show never really lost the sense of adventure the first LE brought, and while the world in the story isn't quite as elaborate as I hoped it would be, it still gave you a good feel of how vast it is. And I don't have to remind you that the animation quality is superb.
It looks like things are going to get a lot more exciting from here onwards. The Ades war on refugees is escalating, and Giselle's insecurity/stress/doubt might take a toll on their teamwork. This should be fun to watch.
![]() |
What do you know about making Okonomiyaki? |
It's hard to "think" about an anime you're supposed to "feel", but I'll try. Tamayura seems to be a step back from Sato Junichi's Aria, because it's lack in the "other element". Slice-of-life series often needs to be paired with a secondary genre for it to work, and Tamayura being very pure slice-of-life... seems to have some problems. But I still enjoy it a lot as compared to the OVA, as the little ways that Potte grew as a character makes the show lovely. I admit that there are always snooze periods in every episode, but the series has succeeds in the overall feel that makes it a SoL genre. And I'm surprised that I really liked those shots that Potte or the other photographers in the story took; even though those moments didn't really take place in the anime at all.
![]() |
And what do you know about poetry in motion? (this scene is fucking epic) |
I've dropped this and picked it back up twice. While the series has been incredibly unique and well-presented for how absurd the storyline is, I can't seem to find myself caring about the show. It is entertaining and mildly amusing, but it doesn't make me want to catch the next episode. For all I know, they'll be fighting for another special lunch box with another special fighting style that's uniquely trained in some way. It's like a sports anime for me, a genre which I don't watch.
The problem is, though, I simply have too much free time now and there really isn't enough (good) shows for me. So Ben-To would help me kill time... and make me extremely hungry.
The Below Average
![]() |
I forgot what he said here, but it's likely along the lines of MUHAHAHAHAHA |
Shana 3, much like Horizon, seems to be filled with jargon I couldn't grasp or care about. I know that it might not be a problem if you followed up after the second season (or the novel), but I didn't like it enough to rewatch that (I never rewatch anime series anyway). The story so far has been incredibly slow. They've spent the last 4 or 5 episodes merely setting up the stage for the epic battle that we got a glimpse of in the first few minutes of episode 1, but how long do you plan to entertain me with people simply moving around the world and preparing for the war? Most of them are new characters we barely knew about too. On the bright side, we're spared the Shana tsundere crap and Yoshida stopped looking like she got dumped every two hours.
![]() |
I can't believe he wore the fucking bikini. |
It pisses me off to see Kodaka not helping Yukimura get a clue about Yozora's bullshit.
It pisses me off to see Rika and her sick fetishes.
It pisses me off to see Yozora.
It wasn't as bad as before, but the animation quality has taken quite a dip since the first episode.
At least there's still Sena. She's supposed to be bitch #2, but I can't help but like her.
The Bad
![]() |
Couldn't be more obvious what kind of character they're trying to paint Inori as. |
I'm still waiting (or hoping) for the good part to start. Maybe I'm in denial, but a part of me refuses to believe that Hiroyuki Yoshino (of Code Geass, Mai-HiME, Gundam SEED and Macross Frontier) could pen something like this. I'll like to think that they wrote this with an epic plot twist or ending in mind, and they're just doing whatever they want before they got there. "Epic" as in Madoka-level epic, enough for them to not care about what's really going on in the final product.
I get the feeling I'll be disappointed in the end anyway. They've reached new heights on not giving a shit about what the audience thinks. I haven't seen anything so bad since Tayutama. And the characters are way too bland and inconsistent to make a plot twist work, much less an ending.
I wish I picked another show to blog. Damn you Guilty Crown, for making me feel guilty if I dropped this.
Others
Kyoukai Senjou no Horizon (On-Hold at episode 4)
Mawaru Penguindrum (On-Hold at episode 8)
Mashiro-Iro Symphony (Dropped at episode 3)
Anime-Source.com First Impressions (and my early october roundup)
Posted by
du5k
Labels:
Anime Source,
Ben-To,
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai,
Guilty Crown,
Kyoukai Senjou no Horizon,
Last Exile: Ginyoku no Fam,
Mashiro-iro Symphony,
Shakugan no Shana,
Tamayura,
Working
The first impressions I've co-written at Anime-Source.com is out! Thanks to fellow writers Himitsu, Chikage_Shampoo, eisenmeteor and AJtheFourth from Altair & Vega. Disclaimer: Most of my contributions are rehashed opinions I've written on this blog, and probably aren't too useful for well-informed readers of the blogosphere. Still, go check it out.
This Season Sucks (Quick first impressions on everything. Almost. Half, actually)
Posted by
du5k
Labels:
Ben-To,
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai,
C3,
First Impression,
Gundam,
Ika Musume,
Kyoukai Senjou no Horizon,
Maken-ki,
Mashiro-iro Symphony,
Mirai Nikki,
Shakugan no Shana,
Tamayura,
Working
No intro. Lets just start with the first impressions.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)